8+ Pool Stabilizer: What It Does & Why You Need It


8+ Pool Stabilizer: What It Does & Why You Need It

Cyanuric acid, generally referred to within the context of swimming swimming pools, acts as a protecting agent for chlorine. It mitigates the degradation of chlorine molecules attributable to ultraviolet radiation from daylight. With out this safety, chlorine dissipates quickly, rendering it ineffective at sanitizing the pool water and controlling algae and micro organism progress.

Using this compound is essential for sustaining satisfactory sanitation ranges in out of doors swimming swimming pools. By extending the lifespan of chlorine, it reduces the frequency and quantity of chlorine wanted, resulting in value financial savings and doubtlessly minimizing pores and skin and eye irritation for swimmers. Its implementation has change into a regular apply for the reason that mid-Twentieth century, considerably enhancing pool water high quality administration.

The following sections will delve into optimum focus ranges, strategies of utility, potential drawbacks of extreme use, and testing procedures, offering a whole information to understanding and using this important pool chemical.

1. Chlorine safety

The elemental relationship between chlorine safety and cyanuric acid lies within the latter’s capability to defend chlorine from photolysis. Photolysis is the decomposition of chlorine molecules induced by ultraviolet (UV) radiation current in daylight. Unprotected chlorine in an outside swimming pool undergoes speedy degradation through this course of, diminishing its focus and, consequently, its sanitizing capabilities. Cyanuric acid mitigates this by forming a reversible bond with chlorine. This bonding reduces the speed at which chlorine is destroyed by daylight. Because the chlorine is consumed, the cyanuric acid releases it, offering a reservoir of obtainable chlorine, enhancing the effectivity of pool sanitation. With out this protecting mechanism, sustaining efficient chlorine ranges would necessitate excessively frequent additions, proving pricey and impractical. For instance, a pool uncovered to direct daylight would possibly lose practically all its free chlorine inside a couple of hours if cyanuric acid is absent.

This safety just isn’t absolute; cyanuric acid doesn’t render chlorine invulnerable to UV radiation. Quite, it acts as a buffer, slowing down the decomposition price. The best focus of cyanuric acid is a steadiness. Too little gives inadequate safety, whereas extreme ranges can scale back chlorine’s sanitizing efficacy. Sustaining a really helpful focus (usually between 30-50 ppm) is essential for optimum chlorine efficiency. Actual-world examples exhibit that swimming pools with correctly stabilized chlorine expertise far fewer algae blooms and require much less frequent shock therapies, decreasing each chemical consumption and upkeep labor.

In abstract, chlorine safety is a crucial operate of cyanuric acid, instantly affecting the effectivity and cost-effectiveness of pool sanitation. Understanding this relationship allows knowledgeable choices relating to pool water chemistry administration, resulting in more healthy and extra fulfilling swimming environments. The first problem lies in sustaining the proper steadiness, stopping each under-stabilization and over-stabilization, which necessitates common water testing and adjustment.

2. UV Radiation Defend

The capability of cyanuric acid to operate as a “UV radiation defend” instantly correlates with its efficacy as a pool stabilizer. This shielding impact underpins the compound’s important position in sustaining applicable chlorine ranges in out of doors swimming swimming pools.

  • Photolysis Mitigation

    Cyanuric acid molecules bind to chlorine, decreasing the speed at which it undergoes photolysisthe breakdown of chemical bonds attributable to UV radiation. With out this defend, daylight quickly degrades chlorine, rendering it ineffective. For instance, in a pool uncovered to intense daylight with out stabilizer, chlorine ranges can drop to close zero inside hours, necessitating frequent replenishment.

  • Reversible Bonding Mechanism

    The bond between cyanuric acid and chlorine is reversible. Which means that whereas chlorine is protected against UV radiation, it stays out there to sanitize the pool water. As free chlorine is consumed, the cyanuric acid releases extra to keep up a constant focus. This dynamic equilibrium permits for extended sanitizing motion in comparison with unstabilized chlorine.

  • Focus Dependency

    The effectiveness of the UV radiation defend is instantly depending on the focus of cyanuric acid within the pool water. Inadequate ranges present insufficient safety, resulting in speedy chlorine loss. Conversely, extreme ranges can hinder chlorine’s sanitizing exercise. Sustaining the proper focus, usually between 30-50 ppm, is essential for optimum safety in opposition to UV radiation with out compromising chlorine’s main operate.

  • Affect on Pool Chemistry

    The UV radiation defend not solely extends chlorine’s lifespan but additionally contributes to total pool chemistry stability. By stopping drastic fluctuations in chlorine ranges, it reduces the frequency of chemical changes and minimizes the potential for algae blooms and bacterial progress. This stabilizing impact promotes a more healthy and extra balanced swimming surroundings.

In essence, the “UV radiation defend” created by cyanuric acid is paramount to understanding its position in pool upkeep. It instantly impacts chlorine longevity, sanitizing efficacy, and total pool water stability. Correct administration of stabilizer ranges is, due to this fact, integral to efficient pool care and bather security.

3. Sanitizer Lifespan

The period for which a pool sanitizer stays efficient is considerably influenced by cyanuric acid, a chemical generally utilized in swimming swimming pools. The presence of cyanuric acid instantly impacts the persistence of chlorine, probably the most prevalent sanitizer, within the water. Understanding this relationship is essential for efficient pool upkeep.

  • Photodegradation Inhibition

    Chlorine molecules are prone to degradation by ultraviolet radiation from daylight, a course of generally known as photodegradation. This course of quickly reduces the focus of chlorine within the water, diminishing its sanitizing capability. Cyanuric acid mitigates photodegradation by forming a protecting bond with chlorine molecules, extending their lifespan. With out this safety, chlorine would dissipate shortly, requiring frequent replenishment. For example, in a pool uncovered to direct daylight, unstabilized chlorine would possibly solely final a couple of hours, whereas stabilized chlorine can stay efficient for a number of days.

  • Stabilization Mechanism

    The stabilization mechanism includes a reversible response between cyanuric acid and chlorine. Cyanuric acid binds to chlorine, shielding it from UV radiation. When microorganisms or different contaminants enter the water, the bond weakens, releasing chlorine to carry out its sanitizing operate. This dynamic equilibrium ensures that chlorine stays out there to fight contaminants whereas being protected against degradation. The result’s a extra constant and extended sanitizing impact in comparison with utilizing chlorine alone.

  • Focus Affect

    The focus of cyanuric acid instantly impacts the sanitizer lifespan. Inadequate ranges of cyanuric acid provide insufficient safety, resulting in speedy chlorine loss. Conversely, extreme ranges can scale back chlorine’s efficacy by hindering its capability to oxidize contaminants. Sustaining the really helpful cyanuric acid focus, usually between 30-50 components per million (ppm), is crucial for optimizing sanitizer lifespan with out compromising its sanitizing energy. Common water testing is critical to make sure that the cyanuric acid focus stays throughout the optimum vary.

  • Financial Implications

    Extending the sanitizer lifespan via using cyanuric acid has important financial implications. By decreasing the frequency of chlorine additions, pool house owners can decrease their chemical prices. Moreover, sustaining a secure chlorine degree minimizes the chance of algae blooms and bacterial progress, decreasing the necessity for pricey shock therapies and different corrective measures. A stabilized pool requires much less frequent monitoring and adjustment, saving each time and assets. The long-term financial advantages of utilizing cyanuric acid are substantial.

The connection between cyanuric acid and sanitizer lifespan highlights the significance of chemical steadiness in pool upkeep. By understanding and managing the components that affect sanitizer longevity, pool house owners can obtain efficient sanitation, scale back prices, and keep a wholesome swimming surroundings. The important thing lies in sustaining the proper steadiness of cyanuric acid and chlorine, monitored via common testing and adjusted as wanted.

4. Algae management

The presence of cyanuric acid in swimming pool water instantly influences the effectiveness of chlorine in stopping algae progress. Algae management depends on sustaining an satisfactory degree of free chlorine, which acts as a sanitizer to remove algae spores and inhibit their proliferation. Cyanuric acid, when correctly managed, considerably extends the lifespan of free chlorine by mitigating its degradation from ultraviolet radiation. Consequently, a secure degree of chlorine is maintained, offering steady safety in opposition to algae blooms. With out enough cyanuric acid, chlorine dissipates quickly, creating alternatives for algae to thrive, even with frequent chlorine additions. For example, a pool uncovered to intense daylight with inadequate cyanuric acid could expertise recurring algae issues regardless of common chlorination, demonstrating the crucial position of stabilizer in sustaining efficient algae management.

Actual-world examples illustrate the sensible significance of this understanding. Swimming swimming pools with stabilized chlorine expertise fewer algae outbreaks, decreasing the necessity for algaecides and shock therapies. This interprets to decrease chemical prices and diminished pool upkeep labor. Furthermore, the soundness afforded by cyanuric acid permits for extra predictable water chemistry, minimizing fluctuations that may contribute to algae progress. Industrial swimming pools, particularly, profit from this stability, as constant water high quality is crucial for sustaining a protected and fulfilling swimming surroundings for a lot of customers. The influence extends to residential swimming pools as effectively, the place owners can get pleasure from clearer water and diminished algae-related upkeep by adhering to really helpful cyanuric acid ranges.

In abstract, the correlation between algae management and stabilizer use is clear. Cyanuric acid enhances the efficacy of chlorine by defending it from daylight, thereby stopping algae proliferation. This understanding is essential for efficient pool administration, enabling pool operators and owners to keep up cleaner, more healthy water with diminished chemical consumption and labor. The problem lies in sustaining applicable cyanuric acid concentrations, avoiding each under-stabilization, which ends up in speedy chlorine loss and algae progress, and over-stabilization, which might scale back chlorine’s sanitizing energy. Common water testing and adjustment are important for optimum algae management and total pool water high quality.

5. Water readability

The visible attraction and security of a swimming pool are intrinsically linked to water readability. The effectiveness of chlorine, the first sanitizing agent, in sustaining this readability is instantly influenced by the presence and focus of cyanuric acid. This relationship highlights the compound’s oblique, but important, contribution to the aesthetic and useful features of pool upkeep.

  • Stabilization and Chlorine Efficacy

    Cyanuric acid protects chlorine from degradation attributable to ultraviolet radiation, extending its lifespan. Extended chlorine effectiveness interprets to a extra constant oxidation of natural matter and contaminants that cloud the water. Inadequate stabilization results in speedy chlorine depletion, permitting these substances to build up and diminish water readability. A direct consequence of insufficient stabilizer ranges is usually turbid or murky water, detracting from the pool’s look and doubtlessly compromising hygiene.

  • Algae Prevention and Transparency

    Clear water is usually indicative of a pool free from algae blooms. Algae, even in small concentrations, can drastically scale back water readability, making a inexperienced or cloudy look. By stabilizing chlorine, cyanuric acid not directly prevents algae progress, thereby preserving water transparency. Optimum stabilizer ranges make sure that chlorine stays efficient at inhibiting algae proliferation, leading to clearer and extra inviting swimming situations. This preventive motion in opposition to algae is essential for sustaining visually interesting pool water.

  • Suspended Solids Administration

    Though cyanuric acid doesn’t instantly take away suspended solids, its influence on chlorine efficacy impacts their visibility. Properly-stabilized chlorine oxidizes natural particles, decreasing their dimension and making them extra simply filterable. This course of minimizes the presence of seen particles, contributing to improved water readability. In distinction, unstabilized chlorine struggles to maintain tempo with the introduction of contaminants, resulting in an accumulation of suspended solids that scatter mild and scale back transparency. Constant oxidation is essential to sustaining a transparent and welcoming pool surroundings.

  • Balanced Chemical Atmosphere

    Sustaining correct water readability is reliant on a chemically balanced pool surroundings. Cyanuric acid, as a chlorine stabilizer, performs a job on this steadiness. Fluctuations in chlorine ranges attributable to insufficient stabilization can necessitate frequent chemical changes, doubtlessly disrupting the general water chemistry and impacting readability. A secure chlorine degree, facilitated by applicable stabilizer concentrations, permits different pool chemical compounds to operate optimally, creating situations conducive to clear, glowing water. Common water testing and adjustment are important for preserving this steadiness and maximizing readability.

These interconnected components reveal that whereas cyanuric acid doesn’t instantly make clear water, its position in stabilizing chlorine is indispensable for sustaining the situations mandatory for optimum water readability. The safety it provides permits chlorine to carry out its sanitizing and oxidizing features successfully, resulting in cleaner, clearer, and extra interesting swimming pool water.

6. Diminished chlorine consumption

The power to lower the quantity of chlorine required for efficient pool sanitation is a direct consequence of using cyanuric acid as a stabilizer. This discount in consumption has implications for value financial savings, environmental influence, and swimmer consolation.

  • Mitigation of Photodegradation

    Cyanuric acid’s main operate is to defend chlorine from ultraviolet (UV) radiation, which causes speedy decomposition of chlorine molecules. With out this safety, chlorine dissipates shortly, necessitating frequent additions to keep up satisfactory sanitation ranges. By decreasing the speed of photodegradation, cyanuric acid prolongs the lifespan of chlorine, thereby reducing the general quantity wanted. Instance: A pool with out stabilizer could require chlorine additions every day, whereas a stabilized pool would possibly solely want them each few days.

  • Optimized Sanitization Effectivity

    Stabilized chlorine displays a extra constant and sustained sanitizing impact. The reversible binding between cyanuric acid and chlorine permits for a managed launch of chlorine as it’s consumed. This mechanism ensures that chlorine stays out there to neutralize contaminants over an extended interval, optimizing its sanitization effectivity. In distinction, unstabilized chlorine fluctuates extra dramatically, resulting in durations of over-chlorination adopted by durations of inadequate sanitation.

  • Decreased Chemical Prices

    Decrease chlorine consumption instantly interprets to diminished expenditure on pool chemical compounds. Stabilizing chlorine decreases the frequency with which chlorine should be bought and added to the pool. This value saving may be important, significantly for bigger swimming pools or these situated in areas with excessive daylight publicity. For instance, a business pool operator utilizing cyanuric acid can anticipate to see a noticeable lower of their annual chlorine funds.

  • Environmental Advantages

    Decreased chlorine consumption has constructive environmental ramifications. The manufacturing and transportation of chlorine contribute to environmental air pollution. By decreasing the demand for chlorine, stabilizer not directly lessens these environmental impacts. Moreover, decrease chlorine concentrations in pool water can decrease the potential for dangerous byproducts, akin to chloramines, which might negatively have an effect on air and water high quality.

These sides illustrate that cyanuric acid facilitates diminished chlorine consumption by defending chlorine from UV degradation, optimizing its sanitization effectivity, reducing chemical prices, and providing environmental advantages. Its use in pool upkeep represents a balanced strategy to sustaining water high quality whereas minimizing each monetary and ecological burdens. The important thing to realizing these advantages lies in sustaining applicable stabilizer ranges, stopping each under-stabilization and over-stabilization, and repeatedly monitoring water chemistry.

7. Balanced pool chemistry

Attaining balanced pool chemistry is crucial for swimmer security, gear longevity, and total water high quality. The position of cyanuric acid, functioning as a stabilizer, instantly influences this steadiness by affecting the habits and efficacy of chlorine, a key part in pool sanitation. Understanding this connection is crucial for efficient pool administration.

  • Chlorine Stabilization and pH

    Unprotected chlorine is very prone to pH fluctuations. At increased pH ranges, chlorine turns into much less efficient as a sanitizer. Cyanuric acid stabilizes chlorine, making it much less delicate to those pH variations, thereby serving to to keep up constant sanitation ranges. For instance, in a pool with excessive pH, unstabilized chlorine could also be rendered ineffective, requiring frequent changes and doubtlessly inflicting pores and skin irritation. Steady chlorine, facilitated by applicable cyanuric acid ranges, reduces the necessity for such drastic pH corrections.

  • Alkalinity and Corrosion Management

    Whole alkalinity acts as a buffer in opposition to speedy pH modifications. Cyanuric acid’s affect on chlorine stability not directly impacts alkalinity administration. By sustaining a extra secure chlorine degree, the necessity for frequent additions of pH-adjusting chemical compounds is diminished, which in flip minimizes fluctuations in alkalinity. Correct alkalinity ranges are important for stopping corrosion of pool gear and plaster, prolonging their lifespan and decreasing upkeep prices. Swimming pools with persistently balanced chlorine and alkalinity, because of stabilization, exhibit fewer corrosion points.

  • Calcium Hardness and Scale Formation

    Calcium hardness refers back to the quantity of dissolved calcium within the water. Imbalances in calcium hardness can result in scaling or etching of pool surfaces. Whereas cyanuric acid doesn’t instantly have an effect on calcium hardness, its influence on chlorine stability helps stop situations that exacerbate calcium-related issues. For example, broad swings in pH, typically related to unstable chlorine ranges, can promote calcium scale formation. By sustaining secure chlorine ranges via stabilization, the chance of pH-induced scale is minimized, contributing to the longevity and look of pool surfaces.

  • Whole Dissolved Solids (TDS) Administration

    Whole dissolved solids signify the cumulative focus of all dissolved substances within the water, together with chemical compounds, minerals, and natural matter. Whereas cyanuric acid provides to the TDS degree, its advantages in stabilizing chlorine and decreasing the necessity for different chemical compounds can not directly contribute to decrease total TDS. Frequent stunning or using extreme algaecides, typically necessitated by unstable chlorine, can considerably enhance TDS. By sustaining secure chlorine ranges with cyanuric acid, pool house owners can decrease the necessity for these further therapies, serving to to regulate TDS buildup.

The multifaceted affect of cyanuric acid on chlorine habits and its oblique results on pH, alkalinity, calcium hardness, and TDS underscore its significance in reaching balanced pool chemistry. Sustaining applicable stabilizer ranges is crucial for making a protected, snug, and sustainable swimming surroundings. Swimming pools with diligently managed stabilizer ranges expertise fewer chemical imbalances, resulting in diminished upkeep necessities and a more healthy swimming expertise.

8. Value-effectiveness

The financial benefits of using cyanuric acid in swimming swimming pools are primarily derived from its capability to increase the lifespan of chlorine. By mitigating the consequences of ultraviolet radiation, cyanuric acid reduces the frequency with which chlorine should be added to keep up satisfactory sanitation ranges. This lower in chlorine demand instantly interprets into decrease chemical prices over time. The preliminary funding in cyanuric acid is usually offset by the following financial savings on chlorine purchases, making it a cheap answer for pool upkeep. For instance, a business pool operator in a sun-drenched area would possibly observe a big discount in month-to-month chlorine bills by implementing a cyanuric acid stabilization program, thereby enhancing the pool’s operational effectivity.

Moreover, the cost-effectiveness extends past direct chemical bills. Correctly stabilized swimming pools are much less vulnerable to algae blooms and bacterial outbreaks. These occasions necessitate pricey shock therapies and algaecide purposes to revive water high quality. By stopping these incidents, cyanuric acid contributes to a discount within the want for supplemental chemical therapies. The diminished incidence of water high quality points additionally interprets into decrease labor prices related to pool cleansing and upkeep. Due to this fact, the financial advantages of cyanuric acid prolong to each chemical provides and labor bills. Contemplate a house owner who, after appropriately stabilizing their pool, finds they should shock the pool far much less typically, decreasing each their chemical bills and the time spent on pool upkeep.

In abstract, the cost-effectiveness of cyanuric acid stems from its capability to scale back chlorine consumption, decrease the necessity for corrective chemical therapies, and decrease labor prices. This interprets into important financial financial savings for each residential and business pool house owners. Whereas sustaining correct cyanuric acid ranges requires preliminary funding and common monitoring, the long-term monetary benefits usually outweigh these prices. The important thing to maximizing cost-effectiveness lies in adhering to really helpful focus ranges and using constant water testing protocols. The challenges are minimal in comparison with the monetary implications of not stabilizing chlorine in out of doors swimming swimming pools.

Regularly Requested Questions About Pool Stabilizer

The next addresses widespread inquiries relating to the operate and utility of pool stabilizer, also called cyanuric acid, in swimming pool upkeep.

Query 1: What focus of stabilizer is perfect for out of doors swimming swimming pools?

The widely really helpful focus ranges from 30 to 50 components per million (ppm). This vary gives satisfactory safety in opposition to ultraviolet degradation of chlorine whereas minimizing potential damaging results on chlorine’s sanitizing efficacy.

Query 2: How is stabilizer usually launched right into a swimming pool?

Stabilizer is launched both in granular type instantly into the skimmer or as a liquid answer. The granular type dissolves slowly, so placement within the skimmer permits it to dissolve regularly because the circulation system operates. Liquid stabilizer gives a quicker dissolution price.

Query 3: Can extreme stabilizer ranges be detrimental to pool sanitation?

Sure, extreme stabilizer ranges above 100 ppm can impede chlorine’s capability to successfully sanitize the water. This situation, generally known as “chlorine lock,” necessitates dilution of the pool water to scale back the stabilizer focus to an appropriate vary.

Query 4: How ceaselessly ought to stabilizer ranges be examined in a swimming pool?

Stabilizer ranges must be examined not less than month-to-month, or extra ceaselessly if important water substitute happens attributable to backwashing, leaks, or dilution. Common testing ensures that the focus stays throughout the really helpful vary.

Query 5: Is stabilizer mandatory for indoor swimming swimming pools?

Stabilizer is usually not required for indoor swimming swimming pools as a result of they aren’t uncovered to direct daylight. The absence of ultraviolet radiation eliminates the necessity for chlorine safety.

Query 6: Can stabilizer be faraway from pool water if the focus is simply too excessive?

The first technique for decreasing stabilizer focus is partial draining and refilling of the pool with contemporary water. There aren’t any chemical therapies that successfully take away stabilizer with out additionally affecting different water parameters.

In abstract, sustaining applicable stabilizer ranges is essential for environment friendly chlorine utilization and total pool water high quality. Common testing and adherence to really helpful focus ranges are important practices.

The following part will focus on troubleshooting widespread points related to pool stabilizer and supply steerage on sustaining optimum water chemistry.

Optimizing Cyanuric Acid Use

Efficient administration of cyanuric acid concentrations is essential for maximizing chlorine effectivity and sustaining pool water high quality. The next suggestions present steerage on greatest practices for utilizing this compound.

Tip 1: Take a look at Water Frequently: Conduct routine water exams to watch cyanuric acid ranges. A testing frequency of not less than as soon as monthly is really helpful. Changes must be made primarily based on the outcomes to keep up concentrations throughout the optimum vary of 30-50 ppm.

Tip 2: Add Stabilizer Regularly: When rising cyanuric acid ranges, introduce the chemical in small increments. This strategy prevents overshooting the goal focus and simplifies subsequent changes.

Tip 3: Account for Water Alternative: Important water substitute attributable to backwashing, leaks, or intentional dilution impacts cyanuric acid focus. Re-testing is critical after substantial water loss and substitute to make sure correct ranges are maintained.

Tip 4: Contemplate Liquid Stabilizer for Quicker Dissolution: Liquid cyanuric acid dissolves extra quickly than granular kinds. This may be advantageous when a fast adjustment to stabilizer ranges is required, akin to after heavy rainfall or important dilution.

Tip 5: Monitor Chlorine Ranges Carefully: As cyanuric acid influences chlorine efficacy, carefully monitor free chlorine ranges. Changes to chlorine dosage could also be mandatory to keep up satisfactory sanitation primarily based on stabilizer focus.

Tip 6: Forestall Over-Stabilization: Extreme cyanuric acid ranges (above 100 ppm) can scale back chlorine’s effectiveness. Dilution by partially draining and refilling the pool is the first technique for correcting over-stabilization. Preventive measures, akin to gradual addition, are preferable.

Tip 7: Observe Pool Situations: Frequently observe the pool water for indicators of algae progress or cloudiness. These indicators could recommend imbalances in cyanuric acid or chlorine ranges, necessitating additional testing and adjustment.

Correct implementation of the following tips will assist keep optimum cyanuric acid ranges, resulting in extra environment friendly chlorine utilization, diminished chemical prices, and a more healthy swimming surroundings.

The following part will summarize the important thing advantages of understanding and successfully managing cyanuric acid concentrations in swimming swimming pools.

What Does Swimming Pool Stabilizer Do

This exposition has clarified the essential position of cyanuric acid in swimming pool upkeep. The chemical acts primarily as a defend, defending chlorine from speedy degradation attributable to ultraviolet radiation. This protecting operate extends the lifespan and enhances the efficacy of chlorine, instantly impacting algae management, water readability, and total pool sanitation. Understanding and managing stabilizer concentrations, due to this fact, interprets to diminished chlorine consumption, value financial savings, and a extra balanced chemical surroundings.

The knowledge introduced underscores the significance of knowledgeable pool administration practices. Common water testing and adherence to really helpful stabilizer ranges are important for optimizing pool water high quality and guaranteeing a protected and fulfilling swimming expertise. The rules outlined present a basis for accountable pool stewardship, contributing to the longevity of pool gear and the well being of swimmers. Constant utility of those rules will yield demonstrably higher pool water situations.